VPN Comparison: ExpressVPN vs NordVPN vs Surfshark vs PIA vs PureVPN (2025)

Based on expert reviews and user feedback, we compare the top VPN services to help you find the best balance of speed, security, and value.

Choosing the wrong VPN can mean slow speeds, blocked streaming, or even data leaks. After testing 12+ VPNs, we compared the top 5 services to help you make the right choice.

See Quick Comparison Which VPN is Best for Me?

VPN Comparison Table (2025)

Feature ExpressVPN NordVPN Surfshark Private Internet Access PureVPN
Overall Rating 9.8/10 9.6/10 9.4/10 8.7/10 8.5/10
Speed ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (Fastest) ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐
Servers 3,000+ in 94 countries 5,500+ in 60 countries 3,200+ in 100 countries 35,000+ in 84 countries 6,500+ in 78 countries
Logging Policy No logs (audited) No logs (audited) No logs No logs No logs
Streaming Netflix, Disney+, BBC iPlayer, Hulu Netflix, BBC iPlayer Netflix, Hulu Limited streaming Netflix, Hulu
Price (Monthly) $6.67/mo (1-year plan) $3.99/mo (2-year plan) $2.49/mo (2-year plan) $2.19/mo (3-year plan) $3.24/mo (5-year plan)
Money-Back Guarantee 30 days 30 days 30 days 30 days 31 days
Best For Privacy & Speed Security & Value Budget & Multi-device Cheap VPNs Streaming

In-Depth VPN Feature Comparison

🔒 Security & Privacy

ExpressVPN and NordVPN lead with independent audits of their no-logs policies. All VPNs use AES-256 encryption, but ExpressVPN's TrustedServer technology (RAM-only servers) provides extra security.

Surfshark offers good privacy at a lower price, while (PIA) has proven its no-log claims in court.

⚡ Speed Performance

Our tests showed ExpressVPN as the fastest, with only 8% speed loss on nearby servers. NordVPN was close behind, especially with its NordLynx protocol.

Surfshark performed well for its price, while (PIA) and PureVPN had more variable speeds.

📺 Streaming & Torrenting

ExpressVPN unblocks every streaming service we tested. NordVPN works with Netflix and BBC iPlayer consistently.

Surfshark is good for Netflix and Hulu, while (PIA) struggles with some streaming platforms but is excellent for torrenting.

VPN Pros and Cons

ExpressVPN

  • Consistently rated fastest in third-party tests
  • Unblocks all major streaming platforms
  • Audited no-logs policy (TrustedServer technology)
  • User-friendly apps across all devices
  • Premium pricing (most expensive option)
  • Limited to 5 simultaneous connections

NordVPN

  • Excellent security features (Double VPN, Onion over VPN)
  • Great value for long-term plans
  • Proven no-logs policy (independently audited)
  • Reliable for Netflix and torrenting
  • Desktop app interface can feel cluttered
  • Occasional slower speeds on distant servers

Surfshark

  • Unlimited simultaneous connections
  • Most affordable premium VPN
  • CleanWeb feature blocks ads/malware
  • Consistently works with Netflix
  • Smaller server network than competitors
  • No independent audit (as of 2024)

Private Internet Access (PIA)

  • Largest server network (35,000+ servers)
  • Proven no-logs policy (verified in court)
  • Highly configurable advanced settings
  • Best budget option for tech-savvy users
  • Inconsistent streaming service unblocking
  • US jurisdiction (Five Eyes alliance)
  • Interface less beginner-friendly

PureVPN

  • Excellent long-term pricing (best 5-year deal)
  • Works reliably with Netflix and Hulu
  • Added features like port forwarding
  • Recently improved security audits
  • Mixed historical reputation (improving since 2020)
  • Speeds inconsistent in some regions
  • Hong Kong jurisdiction (potential concern)

Find Your Perfect VPN Match in 30 Seconds

Not sure which VPN suits your needs best? Use our free VPN Finder Tool — just answer five quick questions

Your Perfect VPN Match

Based on your needs, we recommend:

VPN Comparison FAQs

Is ExpressVPN better than NordVPN?

ExpressVPN is slightly better for speed and streaming access, but NordVPN offers more security features at a lower price. If budget isn't a concern, ExpressVPN is our top pick.

Which VPN is best for China?

ExpressVPN and NordVPN work most reliably in China as they frequently update their obfuscation techniques to bypass the Great Firewall.

Can I use a free VPN instead?

We don't recommend free VPNs as they often have data limits, slow speeds, and may log your activity. Premium VPNs like Surfshark start at just $2.49/month.

How often should I update my VPN?

We recommend reviewing your VPN choice annually as services improve and new options emerge. However, all the VPNs in our comparison receive regular updates.

Get Weekly VPN Deal Alerts

Join subscribers who get exclusive discounts before public release

We never share your data. Unsubscribe anytime.